Montgomery v. Lester
Summary: In this case, the Lesters appealed the judgment of the trial court awarding the Montgomerys $200,000 for the injury and death of their thoroughbred house that was caused by the Lesterâs dog. The Lesterâs dog chased after and barked at the horse, causing the horse to attempt to climb a fence which severely injured the horsed. The injuries were so severe that the horse was later euthanized. The Montgomerys filed suit against the Lesters and awarded $200,000 in damages. On appeal, the Lesters argued that the claims filed by the Montgomerys should be dismissed because they have âno personal right to claim the damages assertedâ because âthe registered owner of the horse at issue was Montgomery Equine Center, LLC and not the [Montgomerys].âThe court reviewed the issue and determined that the Montgomerys were entitled to damages because they were the rightful owners of the horse. The court held that âregistration of a horse does not prove ownership under Louisiana Law.â As a result, the court found that although the horse was registered to the Montgomery Equine Center, the Montgomerys were still the owners of the horse and therefore entitled to the damages that were awarded by the trial court judge.