Animal Legal Defense Fund v. U.S. Dept. of Agriculture
Summary: Animal Advocacy Organizations argued the district court erred in ruling United States Department of Agriculture (USDA)'s decision to renew an exhibitorâs license did not violate the Animal Welfare Act (AWA). According to the organizations, the USDA may not renew a license when USDA knows an exhibitor is noncompliant with any animal welfare standards on the anniversary of the day USDA originally issued the license. The 11th Circuit, however, found it had subject matter jurisdiction to review the organizations' challenge to the renewal under the Administrative Procedure Act, and that the USDA's interpretationâwhich did not condition renewal on compliance with animal welfare standards on the anniversary of the license issuance dateâwas a reasonable one. The district courtâs decision was therefore affirmed.